watchmen hbo reddit This is a topic that many people are looking for. unusual-travel-destinations.com is a channel providing useful information about learning, life, digital marketing and online courses …. it will help you have an overview and solid multi-faceted knowledge . Today, unusual-travel-destinations.com would like to introduce to you HBO s Watchmen and Liberalism: Is a Better World Possible? BadEmpanada. Following along are instructions in the video below:
“Is the best series that i have ever watched and that s saying a lot lot because i ve seen lo similar door a s seriously. The show is both and narrative. Ly near perfect. The writing is great i can t imagine that it s look and feel could have been any better the soundtrack flawlessly fits every scene.
The acting and casting are completely on point. And even little details like the transitions were often so well done that i found myself rewinding. Just to see them again. Oh yeah.
By the way spoiler warning for everything. It does start out kind of slow and might even be a bit confusing in the first couple of episodes especially for fans of the comic or the film who might be left wondering just what the relation is but it s so intriguing that you just can t help. But continue watching and boy are you rewarded for it everything about this show was perfectly planned the way that it gradually explains itself expands on seemingly minor details from early episodes and introduces elements from the comic as it goes on is so satisfying to watch. It s like a never ending stream of holy shit.
Sort of moments and not the sort that many other franchises and adaptations. Painfully force either where it s like hey. This character you like yep. They re in this will be taking 80 of the box office hits this year.
Thanks all of it makes perfect sense the narrative benefits from every little tie in that there is likelihood it just this origin story. The way they explain that he wears a hood in a noose because he almost got lynched. I love it the show even explicitly rejects the opportunity to bring one of the surviving main characters back because you know there s just not any real reason to what a novel idea normally these days you d expect them to show up in the final boss fights and do their cool special move against the big bed and help save the day or at the very least telepathically communicating with a main character when it looks like they re down and out and inspire them to get up and continue the fight. But no watchman s just like nah he s in jail.
And he never shows up sorry have man instead luba man. The show also tackles some important contemporary political themes and really takes the kids gloves off in many respects i mean it starts off during the tulsa massacre. Where white supremacists destroyed a black town and massacred its residents because they couldn t bear to see black people succeeding an event that i m sure most us didn t even know happened before watching the series and the main antagonist white supremacist. Creplace klan hordes of rorschach masks straight up saying to the audience here.
So you were never actually supposed to like the violent far right extremist character. Which needed to be said pretty badly considering that people. Like noted professional idiot. Ted cruz county rorschach among their personal heroes.
There s also literally this exchange. Which is just amazing because the scales have tipped way too far and it is extremely difficult to be a white man in america god this series makes all the right people incredibly mad for all the right reasons it rules. But at the same time the protagonists themselves are cops who raid poor communities and brutalize their inhabitants brutally torture people during interrogations and you can steal their identities. Despite.
There being some degree of racial justice in this world with extensive reparations being paid for slavery and historical atrocities and despite their apparently being literal world peace. There s still no real economic justice. Still no class based justice. It s just this capitalist as ever everyone s fate is still decided by the lot they inherit their utility to capital and simple dumb luck.
The us president essentially for life is a democrat and democrats controlled both houses they have had a mandate to do whatever they want for decades..
Yet the country they create is still very similar to the usa of today. All the same hierarchies are still intact billionaires still control everything cops are even less accountable and somehow even more violent despite being disarmed and black people now have better opportunities to get rich and impress. The hell out of poor people. Just like other rich people do oh and they ve colonized via.
Which is barely even touched on beyond some platitudes here in there. It s a great critique of the limits of neoliberal style. Work nests of the fact that you can t have real intersectionality. Without also considering class and colonial legacies at the end of the show.
It s even revealed that the white supremacists were being played by a tech billionaire with a messiah complex. Who s been the real big bad all along. Then this hundred year old white supremacist sex is just unceremoniously disintegrated in an instant. Then lead billionaire antagonist is killed.
In much the same way. And even the other quote. Unquote good billionaire is just knocked out by a guy with a wrench. It straight up says look all of the people keeping us down on a flesh and bone.
They re not better than us. They bleed just like we do these hierarchies can be dismantled a better world is possible and all of that is why i was so disappointed to find that the creator is actually an enlightened centrist who made this gave in critique on the limits of neoliberalism entirely by accident yep that s right. I was fortunate enough to have never seen any of damon lindelof shows before this one jealous aren t you so i wasn t familiar with his previous work. Nor his political leanings until after i d watched at all when i saw this tweet by canadian journalist.
Andre thomas. He was referring to an interview after the show s finale in which lindelof says that in the world. He created white supremacism. Still cannot be defeated the fight against white supremacism is going to be a battle that goes on until the end of time.
Unfortunately i d like to be more pie in the sky. But if i learned anything for the experience of writing the show in reading all the things that i ve been reading its the insidiousness of white supremacy. I don t think that i ever would have even put it in the show. If i felt like we were going to try to convince the audience that it could be defeated okay.
So this is a guy who created a show where in the final 30 minutes or so a powerful secret society of white supremacists is not only shown to be nothing compared to the billionaires who really run the world. But in which they are all literally disintegrated to death in a split second oh and also the solely anti racist black female protagonist becomes an all powerful god yet even in this world that he himself created he still somehow cannot imagine the end of white supremacism. He thinks it ll be around until the end of time. This is of course total nonsense white supremacism isn t something natural.
It s a human intervention. That s only about 400 years old if humans created this idea then humans can also work to dismantle it completely linda loves words here reveal a lot about liberal centrist ideology liberals look at the world around them and see nothing below the surface. They don t ask questions about how the structures that underpin society. Actually came to be and whether they could be replaced with something better for them.
It s all simply the natural order..
Just the way things are and always will be since white supremacy has been around a long time since its adherents currently have political power that means it can never be defeated. Not even by a literal anti racist god who could just teleport every white supremacist in the world into space. Whenever. She wants the implications of this are dire firstly.
Because this means that for the liberal white supremacism is natural and incredibly dangerous thing to believe because it s in line with the thinking of white supremacists themselves and secondly for neoliberalism capitalism and the political systems that uphold it are not just like white supremacy mere centuries old constructs. But rather timeless immutable parts of the world itself. Despite what he shows screams at the viewer. Lindelof does not actually believe that a better world is possible in fact he seems incapable of even imagining one at all if we take this a bit further.
Ignoring the indisputable fact that the author died in 1980. In a traffic accident and analyzed the series more through linda laughs on lands. Then this already bleak unimaginative ideology. Looks.
Even bleaker and less imaginative. It also makes the show seems significantly dumber than it would have if you just lived your life blissfully. Ignorant of one s creator has to say about it uh. What could have been damn you andre you see our buddy damon seems to think that the world.
He created is not so much pratik of neoliberalism as it is of a lack of balance meaning a lack of balance between the democratic party and the republican party warning and light and centrism. Incoming liberals get to things wildly wrong in my opinion as an unabashedly bral. One is we spend way too much time wagging our fingers the second is we don t know when to stop regulating regulation is important it s necessary. But that s what the people on the right legitimately fear so when does it stop.
What is it to be thirty years into a liberal regime that felt like low hanging fruit days delicious not to grab. It s going to be imperfect. You need a two party system in order to achieve some level of balance. It doesn t mean that i m not wildly progressive but if you said to me how do you feel about a senate.
That is divided 70 30. I d say that s no bueno that s not going to be representative of america yep apparently the thing that it fix the world that he created is not fundamental change to the economic status quo. But more republicans in the senate. Okay well let s take a look at the world of the show and ask what in it exactly is not aligned with the morally bankrupt values of the republican party just what is this over regulation that lindelof talks about there s not really that much like sure republicans would definitely hate reparations for slavery and racial violence.
No doubt about that but you know that s really the only big contention that they d have with robert redford s usa. The rest is relatively minor there s the long content warnings on tv. Which are just the strawman of what lindelof thinks people want because literally no one in history has ever asked for anything beyond warnings that are a few seconds long and also they already exist. There s also the second scene in the very first episode.
Where we learn that cops have to ask for permission to unlock and use their guns and the cop. Who is black is murdered by a white supremacist as a result. This was easily the worst scene in the entire show bad enough that i kind of wanted to stop watching. Though i m glad i did in its messaging is just incredibly dumb like what if cops didn t have free use of their guns.
Then they d be killed by white supremacists..
Wow galaxies brain. That s obviously the complete opposite of reality. Where american cops use their guns willy nilly to murder people many of them black for basically whatever reason. They feel like oh and also in real life.
There s kind of lots of white supremacists in the police force in another interview lindelof makes a clear reference to the scene saying that taking everyone s guns away would be really bad in practice. There s already plenty of countries where beat cops. Don t actually carry guns at all. It s not some pie in the sky.
Thing. That only some thirty year long literal dystopia could possibly implement also there s a huge leap from disarming. The police to taking everyone s guns away. The police are not everyone.
But yes republicans would want cops to be as well armed as possible as unaccountable as possible as racist as possible and to oppress the poor as much as possible. The police depicted in the show. Only really do two of those things outside of that stuff. Though.
Republicans would be mostly fine with this america especially since they d be getting paid by the incredibly powerful billionaires that are shown to be manipulating. The world as they please. So the question. Then is how would having a balance between the democrats and the republicans somehow make this world.
Any better would not having reparations make things better would white supremacists. Having open representation government. Rather than just having secret white supremacists in government make things better would cops being more racists and even more brutal than they are today make things better. Yeah.
Nobody you know conservatives love the rich hate. The poor love colonialism. Love police brutality. All that sort of thing.
The only fundamental differences would be the lack of reparations and a more overtly racist government and state security apparatus lindelof seems to believe that he s created a usa. That s very very different. But since most of the same socio economic power relations continue intact. All he s done is given us a glimpse into a marginally less racist america with some flimsy reforms that a conservative government could and would easily destroy in like the first year of its term apparently this society.
That is at its core still very similar to the actual current usa has gone too far and needs more conservatism to balance it out in the passage. I quoted earlier he even specifically said that if 70 percent of elected representative shared similar politics that would be i quote no bueno. I repeat. Because it really needs to be besides people voted for that 70 liberal senate to represent them in this world.
I don t think the electoral systems and the capitalism can possibly be fair at. All but that s beyond the point because the us. Electoral system is rigged to heavily favor the gap over the democrats so a 70 democratic majority especially in the senate. Where all states have equal representation.
That doesn t account for population would be an even bigger rejection of a gap than the percentage already implies. So apparently conservatism and liberalism both deserve equal 50. 50 representation. Just by right who cares.
If people overwhelmingly vote to reject conservatism. Who cares if republicans are well known for harboring and apologizing for the same white supremacist that the show explicitly denounces. There s really no better indictment of liberalism even in damon lindelof. Smile.
De streams. We ve years of unopposed governance by adherents of his ideology. He can still only imagine a world so disappointing that it comes off as a leftist critique of neoliberalism and his solution to this failure is not to look beyond. The american two party mainstream.
But instead to outright reject democracy and pray that the fucking republicans save us even in a liberals wildest dreams. They re compromising with people who hate every fiber of their being i it s so painful. But for me watchmen despite lindelof having such a crappy interpretation of the thing that he himself created ends on a note that very much implies that a better world is possible that white supremacism can be defeated. That people of color would play a pivotal role in its demise and even that white people can be good and worthy allies in the fight against it they re those who hold real power regardless of how righteous and superior.
They believe themselves to be just as fragile as anyone else. And if they can be brought down then the system that they uphold can be brought down too and that neoliberalism even we have no obstacles before it even helped along by the blood sacrifice of free million people. And the clandestine help of shadowy figures with limitless resources could not meaningfully improve the world while the series. Doesn t quite know as far as offering an alternative.
I d like to suggest one myself perhaps rather than the laughable suggestion that more republicans are the answer look towards the left. No not liberalism not even progressivism. The actual left socialism because socialists can imagine an infinitely better world and we are never going to stop fighting for it in conclusion. The most compelling reason to completely ignore or foil intents is that most authors are painfully dumb.
Thanks for watching. If you like this video maybe check out some of my other stuff. Which is all totally different and if you really like my stuff. Then maybe consider supporting me by becoming a patron.
A member on youtube yes. I have those now or by sending me a one time tip on kofi. This is my full time job believe it or not so it all really helps now. I just like to thank all of my patrons and especially my 10 plus patrons tonga peru to niha leftist tech support super pancake man jessie ho sick lautaro marimo igor dosa jilly bean derrick nico of the cestas aldrin nate fawn shanta nerve here abbi christoph kaczynski diego salvati violet rain moomoo shin since your knee brace girl industrial robot one trash boy and ” .
Thank you for watching all the articles on the topic HBO s Watchmen and Liberalism: Is a Better World Possible? BadEmpanada. All shares of unusual-travel-destinations.com are very good. We hope you are satisfied with the article. For any questions, please leave a comment below. Hopefully you guys support our website even more.